X



【反出生主義】 ベネター Part9 【antinatalism】

■ このスレッドは過去ログ倉庫に格納されています
0001考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/05(金) 03:27:53.420
デイヴィッド・ベネター(David Benatar, 1966年12月8日 - )は、
南アフリカケープタウン大学の哲学科長、教授
著書『生まれてこないほうが良かった 存在してしまうことの害悪
(Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence)』において
反出生主義(antinatalism)を擁護したことで最もよく知られている。
同書の主張によれば、誕生し存在するようになることは、存在者の感情の如何に
よらず深刻な害悪であり、したがってこれ以上感覚を有する存在を生み出すことは
常に道徳的に誤っているという

ベネターは、痛みはそれ自体で悪しきものであるという論争の余地がない前提を
もとに議論している。しかしながら、子どもに対する体罰や男児の割礼の擁護も
行っている(保護者の裁量にまかされる事柄だと彼は考えている)。
医療倫理学の分野で頻繁に引用される論文の著者であり、代表作に
「予防と児童虐待の間(Between Prophylaxis and Child Abuse)」
(『The American Journal of Bioethics』)や「胎児の痛み――
胎児の痛みに関する混乱の終息に向けて(A Pain in the Fetus:
Toward Ending Confusion about Fetal Pain)」(『Bioethics』)がある

前スレ
【反出生主義】 ベネター Part3 【antinatalism】
https://lavender.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/philo/1651385234/
【反出生主義】 ベネター Part4 【antinatalism】
https://lavender.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/philo/1651556995/
【反出生主義】 ベネター Part5 【antinatalism】
https://lavender.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/philo/1652499657/
【反出生主義】 ベネター Part6 【antinatalism】
https://lavender.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/philo/1653057033/
【反出生主義】 ベネター Part7 【antinatalism】
https://lavender.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/philo/1656797663/
【反出生主義】 ベネター Part8 【antinatalism】
https://lavender.5ch.net/test/read.cgi/philo/1658181909/
0752考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/17(水) 19:32:49.870
Everyone is alive because they were born.
There is no disadvantage to not being born.
Live in an absurd world with only those who are born because of their parents' dangerous gamble.

Population decline? Good luck with robotics,
don't ask anti-natalists to be responsible.
0753考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/17(水) 20:59:35.210
This is my way of thinking.
The idea that I don't want to have a baby because I feel sorry for the child is "weak anti-natalism".
And "strong anti-natalism" is the idea that all births are evil and all people should not give birth.
And "militant anti-natalism" is one that commands others not to give birth.
The other is "childfree," which means not to have children for one's own comfort.

This thread seems to have a majority of "strong anti-natalists," but the idiot says that anti-natalism only makes sense if it is "militant anti-natalism".
And it is so funny that they are against anti-natalism. Too stupid.
0754考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/17(水) 21:34:39.660
By the way, I have written several articles on the comparison of wild and civilized people,
and this idea was inspired by Rousseau. He has a sharp point of view and is an excellent philosopher.
But alas, the idiotic critics of this thread have said,"That's your impression, isn't it?"You sound like Hiroyuki.
0755考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/17(水) 22:01:07.660
>>753
Continued.
And "strong anti-natalism" is just a personal value.
It doesn't matter if I judge all births to be evil, because I don't force others not to have children.
But I do think all parents have done wrong.
It's a personal thought, so why not?
0757考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/17(水) 22:40:37.690
"I want to be happy with my children.",Why don't you be happy on your own?
Your kids won't necessarily be happy, and you might think, "I wish I hadn't had them."
0758考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/17(水) 22:47:36.380
If a child is born incredibly unhappy, "Why is my child...?" I understand that feeling, but we can make a rational decision in advance that this may happen.
I understand that feeling, but we can rationally determine in advance that this could happen.
"It won't happen! I will make sure they are happy!" This judgment is nothing more than an assumption.
0759考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 03:52:43.170
Part9まで障害者さんがひたすら健常者の中傷してたとはな

「馬鹿」「ゴキブリ」しか言えないのか?

「障害者」と罵ってみろよ
0760考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 03:53:39.060
何語を使っても他人を馬鹿だの猿だの見下す癖が抜けないのはもはや哀れだな

お前のその暴言が嫌われてる原因だと理解できてない、悪いとも思ってないんだろう

これだけ暴言撒いて中傷しておいて「強制してませーん」とかこれもう知能合わせた重複障害者さんだろ

ベネタースレ作ってやりたかった事がヘイト活動とか、そりゃあ論客も相手せず逃げるわな
0761考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 04:35:50.760
Even if mostly people disagree with an idea that conducts to antinatalism,
it can't change present social trends in main developed countries.
It's significant decline of birthrate. Also we need adequate controlled prevention
for high-stakes of overpopulation.
0762考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 04:44:46.590
>>761

US birth rate falls 4% to its lowest point ever

The downward trend in birth rates in the US has been seen throughout the world

The American birth rate fell for the sixth consecutive year in 2020, with the lowest number of
babies born since 1979, according to a new report.Some 3.6 million babies were born in the US in 2020 -
marking a 4% decline from the year before, found the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(CDC) National Center for Health Statistics.

The slump was seen across all recorded ethnicities and origins, according to the findings.
The national picture mirrors a decline in births seen worldwide, a trend some experts say
has been accelerated by the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.
0763考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 04:47:41.180
"It's not worth reading," "Poems," "Diary," "Don't write here."
If you make fun of others as much as you like like and get fired back, you will be a victim
0764考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 05:05:01.660
In the CDC report, demographers examined the country's general fertility rate,
which compares the number of live births with the number of women considered
to be of childbearing age - between 15 and 44 years old.

In 2020, the general fertility rate in the US was about 56 births per 1,000 women - the lowest rate
on record and about half of what it was in the early 1960s.

The decline in birth rates was seen across all measured racial and ethnic groups.
Births dropped by 4% among white, black and Latina women, 9% for Asian women,
3% for Hawaiians and other Pacific Islanders and 7% for Native American and Alaska native women.
0765考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 05:38:56.350
What's the global picture?

The slowing US birth rate is echoed by worldwide trends.

While wealthy countries like Germany and Japan have seen slowing birth rates for some time,
the same is now happening in middle-income countries as well, including Thailand and Brazil.
Globally, the fertility rate is expected to fall below replacement levels - 2.1 births per woman - by 2070, 
according to a 2019 report from the UN.

By the end of this century, the report found, the world's population is projected to virtually stop
growing for the first time in history. And a widely cited study published in the Lancet last year
suggested this population peak would come even earlier - in 2064.
0766考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 05:39:29.910
Between 2020 and 2100, 90 countries are expected to lose population, including two-thirds of
all countries and territories in Europe. According to the UN numbers, Africa is the only region
in the world projected to have strong population growth for the rest of the 21st Century -
mostly concentrated in sub-Saharan Africa.

Similar to trends in the US, the UN has linked falling fertility rates and population growth to gradual delays
in childbearing among women. Though the mean age of childbearing varies widely throughout the world,
overall increases will continue to lower fertility rates and global population growth in turn.
0767考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 05:55:05.980
>>766
Considering worsen global warming,ethnic that can survive around severe global environment,
I guess it's just only African people.
0768考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 05:57:10.020
>>665
まさかこの子供丸出し恥さらし中二病文章を批評しろとシツコク言ってるのか?
自己評価が高すぎてびびるわ、まじでガキなんだな
おもしろいからこれからもベネタースレずっと立ててくれよな(爆笑)

>人間は生きるために汗を流しながらやりたくもない仕事をし、イライラし続けている。
イライラしてんの?

>権力者と金持ちに媚びへつらい、こうした人々に仕える栄誉のために身を粉にする。
媚びへつらってんの?

>自分の卑しさと、こうした人々からうける庇護を誇らしげに示し、自分の奴隷状態を自慢して、奴隷状態に加わろうとしない人々を軽蔑する。
卑しいの?

>また、社会で生きる人間は、他人との相対評価で自己の価値を決定する。
相対評価してるの?

>大層な道徳ですら、アダム・スミスが述べているように、他人からの評価が基準になる場合がある。
場合があるってなに?(こんなん笑い死ぬわ)

>常に他人と自分を比較し、自分が勝っていれば喜び、相手を見下す。自分が負けていれば落ち込み、相手に嫉妬する。
君そんな人間なの?

>この感情の波は人間を翻弄し、解けない呪いのように苦しめる。
苦しいんだね、辛いよね(これでいいか?こんなお母さんみたいなレスが欲しいんか?wwwww)
0769考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 06:25:08.110
>>768
Would you like to discuss in English,if you can? Because arguments in Japanese that have inclining to
emotional anti-intellectual vain exchange like you.
0770考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 06:58:42.170
>>768
Uh, that's exactly what one famous philosopher said...
I made that excerpt because it's amazing that something written a few hundred years ago can be applied directly to the present day, and you can't understand any philosophical thought.
Also, you should write in English.
0772考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 07:27:49.490
If you write something philosophical issues in English, I know its needs additional efforts for most native Japanese.
However,therefore I think Its has sufficient effects because it will reduce frequent futile posts and emotional response.
0773考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 07:44:56.920
他人のことを馬鹿だの猿だの罵るのに「障害者」って罵らないのは何故なんだい?

ベネタースレ立ててPart1からPart9まで延々と健常者への暴言まき散らしてた重複障害者さん?

ただの英語力不足を感情表現ができない事と混同している低知能障害者さん?

我田引水・権威大好き・責任逃れ・英語コンプ・税金泥棒の暴言癖障害者さん?
0777考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 08:22:16.210
子供奴隷スレの女もマヌケだなあれは

「子供が大事」と「健常者が憎い」では思想が全く違うのに

サイコパス障害者に都合良く操られてんのw
0779考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 11:25:22.270
I think all of us would have experienced more or less something malicious aftermath and sorrow,
but human beings hasn't get out of there fully yet.
0780考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 12:29:21.440
Mental illness is another form of suffering to live with.
There is another victim in this thread and he seems to be having a very hard time.
0786考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 14:10:46.510
Part1~9スレ、1年以上に渡ってキチガイ障害者さんが健常者に粘着暴言吐いてたクソスレが何だって?

highbrow?ググったら「知的ぶった(軽蔑的に)」みたいなの出てきたけど?(大爆笑)

爬虫類?が何だって?障害者様は健常者にどんな暴言吐いても許されるのかい?

暴言に耐えかねた介護士さんの恨み買ってブスっと植松されても知らないよ?

ベネター棒による暴力大好きなキチガイ障害者さん?ベネター棒はどこいった?

DV失敗暴言厨の恥晒しキチガイ障害者さん?

復讐も満足にできないとか障害者以前の出来損ないの欠陥品かな?

罪のない障害者さんに失礼だとは思わないのかい?

猿と爬虫類とゴキブリ呼ばわりが大好きな暴言厨キチガイ障害者(ベネタースレ立て人)さん?
0787考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 20:00:28.780
Well,
as you can see, this lunatic is an unfortunate person who has had quite a difficult time in life,
but, although it is inappropriate, I get some strange sense of relief when I see such a person.
The presence of someone inferior to oneself makes one relatively happy.
This is true. I believe Schopenhauer said something similar.
0788考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/18(木) 20:06:44.620
You're awfully obsessed with the disabled, but I guess that's what it's all about...
I pity them.
0791考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 03:20:49.790
I'm sure controlled reason and uncontrolled grisly utterances don't occur simultaneously.
0792考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 04:27:12.100
In Tampa, Thomas Mantz, president of Feeding Tampa Bay, a food bank, has seen demand for food assistance
climb 35-40% over the past six months.

“We all have to be concerned when people who are employed, and responsible,
and a productive part of our communities cannot make ends meet,” said Mantz.

Virginia and Daniel Garcia, who care for three young children, are among those seeking help. Before the pandemic,
Garcia stayed at home to look after the children while her husband worked 40 hours a week finishing drywall.
But his hours were cut during the pandemic, and the family began turning to food banks to supplement their groceries.

Just as work returned, gas and grocery prices began to surge. And then a few months ago, Garcia,
who is diabetic, got gangrene in his foot so badly that it almost had to be amputated, leaving him out of work.
Garcia has applied for work at a school cafeteria, but for now she is using credit cards for expenses like
back-to-school clothes and is counting every penny.
0793考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 04:27:47.180
Grocery costs “just jumped from one day to another,” Garcia said. “The bananas and the tomatoes,
the meats — we’ve lowered our meats, our proteins, because it’s so expensive.”

The possibility of not having enough food looms ever-present for Garcia, who at times went without meals
as a child and has sworn that her own children will not.
0794考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 04:28:22.510
Signals that rising prices are inflicting serious pain on families echo across the Sun Belt. In Miami,
legal aid providers have seen a surge in eviction cases as moratoriums end and rents shoot higher.
People with housing assistance vouchers are struggling to find apartments within the price range
the government has set out, said Sean Rowley at Legal Services Miami, because so few affordable
units are on the market and the government’s payments standards have not kept pace with rising rents.

“We’ve seen low-income households lose their vouchers because they cannot lease an apartment,”
he said, explaining that if someone does not find housing in an allotted time, the benefit will expire.
0795考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 04:54:48.710
Like this ,this world is always full of abundant predicament.
So anti-natalism will be corrected stance
0796考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 04:57:39.490
>>795 ×
Like this ,this world is always full of many kinds' predicament.
So anti-natalism necessarily will be correct stance.
0797考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 05:23:53.950
An endless global warming,pandemic and surging every living cost.
I assume this mean no more need a human beings on the earth.Don't you think so?
0799考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 09:08:02.010
The extinction of the human being will be deemed in the global warming earth.
0800考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 09:28:13.920
適当なネガティブニュースもってきて最後に唐突に「だから反出生は正しい」とくっつけただけの手抜き作業www

乱暴すぎて論理もへったくれもないカスみたいなガキの落書きwww

こんな低レベルなデマゴーグにひっかかるような馬鹿を操ったところで何の得にもならない事が分からない障害者(ベネタースレ立て暴言厨)さんwww

もはや他人を操る行為そのものに没頭してるだけのサイコパスだが頭が弱くて失敗続き、スレも過疎って恥晒してるだけの無様な障害者(ゴキブリ呼ばわり大好き暴言厨)さんwww
0801考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 09:28:47.340
「障害者さんではない」と言えない理由でもあるのかい?www

「障害者さんでないと君の中では成立しない活動」なのかい?www

「障害者さんであること」に対する「こだわり」でもあるのかい?www

嘘でもいいから「私は障害者さんではありません」と言えよベネタースレ立て暴言厨www

「私は障害者さんではありません」←ほらこれをコピペしろよwww

お前の手で貼り付けるんだよ、お前の手で書き込むんだよ「私は障害者さんではありません」という文章をよwww
0804考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 10:43:26.380
This is our rigorous reality of today.For instance global warming,inflation,
frequent massive flood,epidemic, food shortages,racism,poverty,surging energy
and groceries cost. These are all flows that significant devastate and worsen the ecosystem.
So you could say a person who is inclined to anti-natalism would have a point.
0806考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 12:54:36.910
What if human being never had been existed,
this ruined earth by humankind how was it now.
0809考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 13:19:54.790
Let's say he has like a habit of ape.
If so, it will inevitable he tries too many vain posts on this thread.
I guess he has straightforward tendency in a bad sense.
0810考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 14:31:45.580
In some cases people would be better to reflect on its intrinsic value of anti-natalism.
Because this world and society are surrounded by many unfavorable affairs all the time
since beginning of human history.
0821考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 17:24:02.970
He has a received barrage of criticism.
Because his attitude so impolite and rude ,it looks like a caveman.
0822考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/19(金) 17:25:42.070
× >>821
He has received a barrage of criticism.
Because his attitude so impolite and rude ,it looks like a caveman.
0830考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 04:52:43.200
>>811
Where were you until now? You were supposed to be in the zoo at least an hour ago.
You were supposed to being isolated by reason of harming other but were out and about.
0832考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 06:23:09.610
Some natalist pointed out Anti-natalist's faults, and some antinatalist vice versa.
0833考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 07:04:09.020
I think human being would be endangered species in the not too distant future.
Because the ego of humankind to being stayed is an uncontrolled level.

Water stagnation occurs when water stops flowing.Stagnant water can be a major
environmental hazard.
0834考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 10:05:34.900
暴言厨障害者さん(ベネタースレ立て人)www

人を中傷することしか頭にない模様www

こーんなゴミクズによく付き合ってんな反出生スレのモブ共はwww

803 I deem him an ape

809 Let's say he has like a habit of ape.

816 You're a member of the apes.

817 I hope that you'll be able to dialogue as a human beings

818 Where on earth have you been all this time in the jungle?

821 it looks like a caveman.

825 an apes story

827 You're supposed to be in jangle.

830 You were supposed to be in the zoo at least an hour ago.
0840考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 15:10:05.950
>>800
I think your understanding is so superficial interpretation.
You may be lacking basic academic skills.
0841考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 15:10:10.680
>>834
What's up?
Get to the hospital as soon as possible.

You may not be a monkey, but you are a lunatic.
People like you become JOKER under stress.
0842考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 15:37:03.510
He should receive proper medical care.
He has serious personality problems.
He is an example of the misery of this world. We should not have more people like this.
0843考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 15:44:19.400
The stress of being agitated on 5chan could turn you into a JOKER.
Like Kato in Akihabara, the psychological damage is so great that it is not impossible.
0845考える名無しさん
垢版 |
2022/08/20(土) 16:36:39.180
We get poisoned by big industries, does not matter if it is the food industry putting
Kilos of unecessary sugar in food to make you addicted, or tobacco industry
which literally makes you inhale pesticides for money and we just take it,
because fuck it.
■ このスレッドは過去ログ倉庫に格納されています

ニューススポーツなんでも実況